American Idol Top 12

Wow was tonight a surprise! I made my predictions of who would be voted off this week before even seeing them perform, and I was only 50/50. I think the judges shared in my shock with 2 of the outcomes. When they called Jared Cotter up I told Tim I wouldn't be surprised if he went home before they said anything. But when it came down to Sundance Head and Sanjaya Malakar...I was expecting Sundance to stay, but nervous because Sanjaya isn't as good as the rest of the guys, but has managed to stick around, so he does have a big following which made me nervous for good reasons.

With the girls I was glad to see Antonella Barba finally off. I thought she should have been the first to go. I was sure last week that the other girl voted off would have either been Gina Glocksen or Haley Scarnato. I thought Gina was outstanding in her performance this week, so after that I was almost sure Haley would go home. I was thinking Haley and Sabrina Sloan were at the lower end of the girls...but think Sabrina did much better than Haley. So to see the two of them brought out together and told that one was staying and one going I thought surely Sabrina would stay.

My favorite 3 people are: Melinda Doolittle, Blake Lewis, and Gina Glocksen now. We'll see how they continue to do the rest of the show.


  1. Possibly why Sanjaya might stay on for another ep or 2

  2. That's horrible.

  3. I can't believe Sanjaya was not voted off again last night! Good grief! My daughters think he'll last several more episodes...please, America, do the right thing and allow him to go home!